Mother and son avoid jail after their dogs kill woman who stroked them (2024)

A mother and son whose Rottweiler dogs fatally savaged a woman in a 'frenzied' attack have been spared jail.

Animal lover Marie Stevens, 40, whose own dog had previously died, went over to pet the two hounds named Rocky, owned by Brian Walshe, 42, and Frankie, owned by his mother Rachel Walshe, 69.

Mrs Stevens, who was on her way to have an evening meal at her sister's house in Liverpool last August, was first bitten on the arm by Frankie.

She was then mauled by both dogs and left 'ragged' in what was described as a 'frenzied' attack, Liverpool Crown Court heard today.

Mrs Stevens, a care worker from Brighton-le-Sands in Merseyside, was bitten multiple times and had to have skin grafts before being discharged from hospital two weeks later.

But the next day she died at home following deep vein thrombosis and pathologists found 'a direct causation to her death and the dog attack'.

Animal lover Marie Stevens (pictured) whose own dog had died, went over to pet the two hounds in August 2023

Mrs Stevens, a care worker, was mauled by the two Rottweilers and 'ragged' in what was described as a 'frenzied' attack

Both defendants admitted a single charge of owning a dog dangerously out of control causing injury resulting in death on August 18, 2023.

Records showed Frankie had been taken to the vets, after showing signs of aggression, two days before the fatal attack in Park Lane West, Netherton, Liverpool.

Judge Andrew Menary, Recorder of Liverpool, said: 'The circ*mstances of this case are shocking and deeply tragic.

'Marie Stevens was a kind and loving person who particularly loved animals and particularly loved dogs and what happened was a terrible irony.

'That is the problem with huge and powerful dogs like these, this is why the public is so concerned about casual ownership of such animals.'

The court heard neither defendant had any previous convictions and lawyers for both described it as a 'momentary' lapse that allowed the dogs to attack as a pack.

Both were given ten-month prison sentences, suspended for 18 months and a 20-day rehabilitation order.

They were ordered to pay £3,500 for the upkeep of the dogs in police kennels since the attack.

Brian Walshe was also ordered to pay £500 prosecution costs and his mother, a retired NHS nurse, £150.

Judge Menary also ordered the destruction of the dogs and disqualified Mrs Walshe from owning a dog indefinitely and her son for five years.

Some of Mrs Stevens' family stormed out in disgust as Judge Menary said he would suspend the prison sentences.

Judge Andrew Menary KC said: 'Marie Stevens was a kind and loving person who particularly loved animals and particularly loved dogs and what happened was a terrible irony'

Judge Menary ordered the destruction of the two Rottweilers (Stock Image)

Earlier, Robert Dudley, prosecuting, told the court CCTV showed the Walshes and Mrs Stevens walking down the street towards each other.

The dog owners moved out of the way to let her pass but the footage showed a brief interaction before Mrs Stevens put down her bag, extending a hand to stroke Rocky.

Frankie then went for Mrs Stevens, biting her arm, dragging her to the ground and 'ragging' her according to witnesses.

Both dogs began biting Mrs Stevens who was 'screaming' during the attack which lasted just over a minute.

Read More Mother and son appear in court after dog lover, 40, was killed in double Rottweiler attack

Eventually Brian Walshe managed to wrestle the dogs under control, Mr Dudley said.

A dog expert described the incident as 'a frenzied attack by two dogs acting independently but as part of a pack'.

Mrs Stevens suffered multiple wounds to her body and underwent a skin graft beforebeing discharged from hospital on September 1, 2023.

But, on September 3, her husband, Mark Stevens, found her collapsed at home from a blood clot which pathologists concluded was a result of the dog attack.

The Walshes claimed Mrs Stevens ignored a warning not to approach the dogs, but this was dismissed by the judge.

Judge Menary said:'As she approached she asked if she could stroke the dogs, I have no doubt that she did do that.'

In a victim impact statement, Mark Stevens said of his partner of 20 years: 'I'm struggling to find the exact words to describe the utter turmoil I have been left in.

'I can't admit she's gone. I'm lonely. I can't even begin to process what's happened.'

He said his wife had gone to pet the Rottweilers after they had lost their own beloved dog 12 months before, adding, 'That's what makes the way she died even harder to come to terms with.'

Nicola Newton, her sister, said: 'She died after stroking dogs. Who would believe that?'

The defendants, Brian and Rachel Walshe, who attended Liverpool Crown Court (pictured), were given ten months prison sentences, suspended for 18 months and a 20-day rehabilitation order

Jamie Baxter, defending Brian Walshe, said Rachel Walshe had lost the lead of Frankie as the attack began, causing the dogs to go into a frenzy but the son had 'desperately' fought to get back control.

He described Brian Walshe as a 'good person, a hard-working man' who had shown genuine remorse and had been left 'broken' by a 'momentary lapse of attention'.

John Rowan, defending Rachel Walshe, said she was deeply remorseful, and had spent her life looking after others as an NHS nurse and had kept Rottweiler dogs for 30 years.

Mother and son avoid jail after their dogs kill woman who stroked them (2024)

FAQs

What happens when a dog mauls a human? ›

Due to California's strict liability legislation, most dog bite cases are relatively straightforward and end with the dog owner or their insurance provider compensating the injured party for treatment and other expenses.

Should a dog be put down for killing another dog? ›

If an animal is declared dangerous for harming another animal, euthanasia is not usually ordered. Consult with an attorney in your municipality regarding local dangerous dog laws and to represent you in a legal proceeding (if one is commenced) involving harm caused by your dog.

Can a dog treat hurt a human? ›

Dog biscuits may contain high levels of protein or fat, which can be difficult for humans to digest and may cause gastrointestinal upset. Additionally, some dog biscuits may contain artificial colours, flavours or preservatives that are not approved for human consumption and could potentially be harmful.

Will my dog get put down for biting someone? ›

Specifically, euthanasia can be required after the dog bites someone in these instances: (a) if the canine has rabies, or (b) has bitten at least 2 people, or (c) if the dog has bitten and seriously injured someone, and was raised to attack people or to fight.

Can you go to jail if your dog kills another dog? ›

However, the law does not apply when a dog attacks another dog. The dog bite law does not apply because California laws view dogs as personal property. Therefore, if a dog attacks your dog, you need to seek damages from the dog owner under negligence laws.

When should a dog be put down? ›

Signs of poor quality of life in dogs
  1. being withdrawn or quiet.
  2. restlessness, unable to get comfortable or lying in odd positions.
  3. avoiding physical contact.
  4. excessive panting or shaking.
  5. crying or yelping.
  6. difficulty breathing.
  7. disorientation or confusion.
  8. loss of enthusiasm for walks.

What happens if your dog kills someone? ›

In extreme cases, an owner may be charged with negligent homicide when a dog kills someone because the owner's failure to control the animal was reckless or criminally negligent.

What to do if a dog mauls you? ›

What to do if you're bitten by a dog
  1. Wash the wound thoroughly. Run under a cold tap for 10 minutes, even if the skin isn't broken.
  2. Speak to the owner if possible. This might be easier if you know them. ...
  3. Seek medical attention as soon as possible. ...
  4. Report the bite.

How does a dog maul a person to death? ›

Severe and fatal dog attacks have in common that the dog or dogs involved carry out multiple, targeted bites (focused bites to bring the victim down and subsequent bites to the neck and face) and shaking until the victim ceases movement.

What does it mean to be mauled by a dog? ›

: to attack and injure (someone) in a way that cuts or tears skin : to attack (someone) and cause a bloody injury. The girl was mauled (to death) by a dog.

Will a vet put down an aggressive dog? ›

Behavioral euthanasia is humanely ending a dog's life because of severe behavioral issues, such as aggression or extreme anxiety. Humane euthanasia is done by a veterinarian. Dogs who are put down due to behavior problems are often young and healthy, which makes this outcome so difficult for many to understand.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Last Updated:

Views: 5917

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Birthday: 1992-02-16

Address: Suite 851 78549 Lubowitz Well, Wardside, TX 98080-8615

Phone: +67618977178100

Job: Manufacturing Director

Hobby: Running, Mountaineering, Inline skating, Writing, Baton twirling, Computer programming, Stone skipping

Introduction: My name is Wyatt Volkman LLD, I am a handsome, rich, comfortable, lively, zealous, graceful, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.